Skip to Main Content
Members:   Log In Sign Up
Text:  A  A  A
The Mail Bag

Transfer Trash Talk #3

Comments (49)

Ipswich's Connor Wickham is one player that we really should be looking at trying to sign this summer. Ok, he may well cost a lot of money (that we don't have), potentially about £15m, but we should be trying to break the bank for this lad.

He has not long turned 18 and potentially looks a very good player. He scored the winning goal for England against Spain in the European U-17 Championship Final in 2010 and was named Football League Young Player of the Year for 2011. He has scored numerous goals for Ipswich in the Championship and already represented England at U-21 level.

He looks a complete all-round striker after scoring goals by going on amazing dribbles as well as with his head and both feet. He has already attracted interest from the 'big' clubs but Everton should offer him first-team Premier League football straight away rather than a few League Cup appearances at someone like Arsenal or Tottenham and maybe sitting on the bench for a couple of seasons.

I believe Everton can offer these Football League youngsters like Wickham and Chamberlain a lot more than the bigger teams, even if we are just a career stepping stone for a couple of seasons because we can guarantee first-team football and their wages won't break our bank like established stars.

£15m may be a hell of a lot of money to a club like Everton but we desperately need a top class striker, and if he is a success, we could sell him on in a couple of years for about three times as much. The money could be raised by selling Bily and Heitinga, together with the James Vaughan money, should be enough.

Surely this is a better option than the free signings of Bothroyd (29) and Klose (33).

Matthew Lovekin, Brighton     Posted 04/06/2011 at 08:08:05

back Return to the Mail Bag


Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer

Mark Stone
1   Posted 05/06/2011 at 00:35:28

Report abuse

For clarity, where did that valuation come from (£15m)? Have Ipswich put a price on his head?
David Barks
2   Posted 05/06/2011 at 00:54:37

Report abuse

Where the hell are you pulling these values from? Jesus Christ. You think that some kid from Ipswich will be able to be sold for £45 million in a couple of years?!! Wow, how did this even get published?
Erik Dols
3   Posted 05/06/2011 at 01:19:49

Report abuse

FM alert!
David Hallwood
4   Posted 05/06/2011 at 01:32:20

Report abuse

But if he was up for sale there would be a bidding war, and given that he's young & English you couldn't see him go for less than £15m
David Hallwood
5   Posted 05/06/2011 at 01:39:38

Report abuse This where the 15m valuation comes from
Ian Tunstead
6   Posted 05/06/2011 at 01:36:56

Report abuse

Is this the best young player on Football manager or something?

Do these 2 "great young players" sound familiar to this Connor kid?

In 2001, Sinama Pongolle, along with his cousin Anthony Le Tallec were signed from Le Havre AC by Liverpool, after some impressive performances in both the European Under-16 Championship and the Under-17 World Championship. He was named player of the tournament as France won the latter competition,

Would you value those two players at £15m?
Steve David
7   Posted 05/06/2011 at 02:29:17

Report abuse

Good shout but I'd rather have Klose. We haven't got a pot to piss in so our outlay this year will be free transfers plus a £5m somewhere. Honestly, this is getting beyond the joke surely a shares issue needs to be on the cards
Chris Bannantyne
8   Posted 05/06/2011 at 02:13:36

Report abuse

I see where you're coming from... Potentially a disasterous move for Everton though.

Clubs with money can risk it on these wonderkids, no one likes to lose large sums of money, but your Manchesters, arsenals and liverpools of this world can absorb a monetary loss of this kind without disrupting their first team.

Everton would have to sell to buy, and basically throw him in the firsts team. If the kid couldn't hack it, or ended up as another Anichebe then we are fucked. These wonderkids do not sell well at all when they get found out. We buy him for £15mil (for example), he flops, then we would be lucky to get £1-2mil for him from a championship or Scottish side. This kind of loss could potentially cripple us.

Of course, buying any player for a decent sum can prove a risk, but the older already proven players provide less risk. E.g. Bilyaletdinov had proven himself in Russia, and was playing for the national team before we bought him for around £9-10mil. If we were to sell him now, its not unreasonable to suppose we could still get £6-7mil for him from a Russian side, or other foreign side who know what he is capable of. Yeah, its a loss, but it is much easier on the wallet.

In some ways I love the idea of risking it on a child prodigy. It would be great to have some kid come out of nowhere, bagging goals at will and setting the premier league on fire. If the kid wanted to stay, then yay for us, but if he wanted to leave, then chuck a Torres-esque pricetag on his head and enjoy the payday.

The reality is though, that most of these kids disappear like a mist, and we would be stuffed. In saying all this, I've watched this fella play, and my feeling is he will be tearing up the premier league soon, and I will be cursing Everton for not taking the gamble.
Ryan Rosenberg
9   Posted 05/06/2011 at 03:28:49

Report abuse

What ever happened to Araz Abdullayev?
Derek Thomas
10   Posted 05/06/2011 at 08:32:53

Report abuse

Joe Royle 'offered' us Bent on a plate, for something like £3 or 4 mill.

Arshavin, in our games vs Zenit, you could see he was class, was there for the taking, for 'on the ball' management.

Oh yeah, sorry, Everton Management / Marketing does not go together with 'on the ball'...
Richard Dodd
11   Posted 05/06/2011 at 09:31:49

Report abuse

Connor is at the same stage of his development as `Our Jack`-except that he has only ever played in a lower league.Just think,if Jack was an Ipswtch player would you seriously urge Moyes to bid £15M for him?Of course not-what we desperately need is a proven goalscorer-easy to say,difficult to effect.
Gavin Ramejkis
12   Posted 05/06/2011 at 09:38:28

Report abuse

Wickham is just this season's Aaron Young or Gareth Bale before they were signed up to a bigger club, he may or may not make it, the second a club with any money whatsoever are interested that's Everton out of the running as we have fuck all to offer to pay for their services.

Doddy, DM is doing such a good job on "Our Jack" that he looks like he is going backwards; what little time he has been on the pitch he hasn't really impressed and has been put all over the place, Moyes' hard on for utility players seemingly stalling any development with him.
Gavin Ramejkis
13   Posted 05/06/2011 at 09:48:50

Report abuse

D'oh Ramsey not young, trouble with typing up two things at once you mix names
Richard Dodd
14   Posted 05/06/2011 at 09:54:07

Report abuse

That`s more to do with Jack`s injury problems,Gavin, although I have to agree that Moyes seems as uncertain as we are as to what is his best position- he keeps talking him up as `a future centre-half`,but never plays him there!.Perhaps he sees ` the midfield tour`as a way of preparing him for the key defensive role?
Brian Waring
15   Posted 05/06/2011 at 09:58:14

Report abuse

Paper talk is that the shite had an £8m bid turned down, Ipswich are looking for at least £10m.

Norman Merrill
16   Posted 05/06/2011 at 10:26:13

Report abuse

I dont know if Moyes would be prepared to pay £10/15 million for a young player to step into the premier, and thats if we had the money?
In a couple of papers this morning United are supposed to lost interest in Rodwell, if thats true, then where do we stump up any money, for such signings.
Besides, I have a feeling that the kid from Ipswich is destined for one of the richer clubs.
Don Kiddick
17   Posted 05/06/2011 at 10:50:11

Report abuse

If all else fails.....we still have Vic
Sam Hoare
18   Posted 05/06/2011 at 11:54:34

Report abuse

Man u lost interest in surprise really given patchy form this season. Therefore only chance we have of having any double figured transfer money is if we sell Leighton Baines.

Would you take £25m for him. Maybe.

Either way, as said above we cannot afford to spend £15m on a kid who has never played at a top level. Any penny Moyes spends given the current climate will have to be well accounted for.
Paul Smith
19   Posted 05/06/2011 at 12:13:15

Report abuse

I spoke to Luke garbutt about Conner wickham I asked if there was a chance he would come to everton and is he as good as everyone says his reply ws that he's asked Conner about joining everton and they both agreed we couldn't afford him and Luke described him as a class striker with everthing going for him. But basically it won't happen because of evertons finances, sad really!
Trevor Lynes
20   Posted 05/06/2011 at 13:09:40

Report abuse

Fully agree with you Derek #10. It was palpably obvious that Arshavin was well worth a punt and at the time you mention he would have been cheaper... as was Bent and Zamora was another player I suggested but I really do not think our scouts are up to much at all.

We tend to spend/waste money when it has been available and luckily a few of our very cheap acquisitions have proved value for money eg; Cahill, Distin and even Saha who is by a distance the best striker we have (when fit of course).

I reckon that Becks would come good if played with a partner up front. I notice by the way that Baines is being mentioned as a prospective sale to provide funds for DM... Man Utd have supposedly lost interest in Rodwell??? We have no cover at all for Baines as it is...

Ray Robinson
21   Posted 05/06/2011 at 13:23:25

Report abuse

Derek #10, we were interested in Arshavin but it was clear that he was playing the big wages card. When he signed for Arsenal, first thing he allegedly stated was that he thought the wages were "after tax". Not the sort of player that would have ever stayed at Everton in my opinion ? even if we had been able to afford him!
Ben Jones
22   Posted 05/06/2011 at 13:01:53

Report abuse

I don't think that will be a good idea.

Yes, there is no doubt the boy is talented and is the type of striker we need, but we cannot expect an 18 year old to lead the line for us next season.

It's a lot of pressure on him, and I dont think Everton can afford to let that happen. We need more established strikers and do not have the luxury to spend £10 million or so on potential.

James Stewart
23   Posted 05/06/2011 at 14:48:12

Report abuse

It would be stupid to start paying out high transfer fees. The quality available this summer on frees is exceptional.

Klose and Demba Ba would be amazing signings. Both class and offer different qualities.

James Royston
24   Posted 05/06/2011 at 14:49:21

Report abuse

Absolutely No Chance..If we have that sort of money we have to go for someone who has proved he can score in the Prem..Who..? I don't know but in the meantime after his first season's experience and presuming he has had his learning curve, we have to give Becks a chance. Unless !! and as well as hopefully that elusive " someone " arrives.....????
Mark Stone
25   Posted 05/06/2011 at 16:49:33

Report abuse


Everton bought him in January on the agreement he would finish out the remainder of the season on loan at his previous club, which he has been doing. I wouldn't write this lad off yet ... he's only just turned 19! Maybe in a few seasons he will play for us and do well, who knows, but for kno I'm not expecting to see much of him in Royal Blue.
Brian Waring
26   Posted 05/06/2011 at 16:49:34

Report abuse

James ( #23 ) Whilst I agree Demba Ba would be an interesting signing, Klose on the other hand, not.

I don't know how true it is ( Couldn't be arsed checking ) but someone mentioned on another thread that in the last 2 seasons Klose had scored about 10 goals in over 60 games.

Also, Bayern won't pay him the wages he is after, and thats why he can go.
Methinks he will be looking for one last big payday, and thats why we wouldn't get him.
John Daley
27   Posted 05/06/2011 at 18:44:57

Report abuse

I've seen quite a bit of Wickham in the last couple of years and there is no doubt he has fantastic potential. In an ideal world he would be a great signing for the future. Romelu Lukaku is another young forward who looks to have the ability to go on and become really formidable. Unfortunately, both are rumoured to be coveted by clubs with much bigger budgets than Everton.

If we're looking for young prospects to take a punt on then Dale Jennings of Tranmere is probably more within our price range. That's if Blue Bill can manage to scrape a million or so together. I won't hold my breath.
Gavin Ramejkis
28   Posted 05/06/2011 at 18:51:08

Report abuse

Brian I'll answer the Klose stats question as a Germany fan, 2011/12 he's scored 3 goals for the national side in two games, 2010/11 he scored 15 goals in 38 games, 10 of which were for the national team in 9 games, the remainder for Bayern Munich, go back another year to 2009/10 he scored 10 goals in 44 games, 4 goals in 6 appearances for the national squad the remainder for Bayern.

He turns 33 this coming Thursday and is a great striker for the national side, always has been but has slowed considerably for Bayern Munich.
Alan McGuffog
29   Posted 05/06/2011 at 20:23:13

Report abuse

I'd love to see him partnering Messi...maybe if we spend all our funds from selling Vaughan we could get them both.
Jesus wept. What part of " we are goosed" can't you understand ? We would be lucky ? to land a world class striker such as Bothroyd. Wickham ? Long ? FFS...wake up
Brian Waring
30   Posted 05/06/2011 at 21:07:48

Report abuse

Cheers Gavin. Always thought he was shit hot when playing for the national team.

Andrew Laird
31   Posted 06/06/2011 at 08:32:12

Report abuse

I have seen this kid numerous times at Portman Road and many of my friends are season ticket holders at Ipswich. He is 1 very big lump.

He has the potential to be very good, at the moment he is doing ok, nothing more. Ridiculous soundbites such as "World Class" do not apply to this lad at all, Messi, Maradona, Cruyff, Beckenbaur, Ronaldo (Brazil) he most certainly is not.

Can we really afford to pay out over £10million for a player who MAY become better than he is already? No. Would he be the best striker at the club if he joined? No.
John Gee
32   Posted 06/06/2011 at 12:25:55

Report abuse

The hottest player in the championship, scores all kinds of goals.... I've got 2 words for you...


Now, I realise that's technically just one word repeated, but I thought it was worth mentioning twice!
James Boden
33   Posted 06/06/2011 at 12:44:17

Report abuse

£15 million for him? aside from the fact we haven't got a pot (Thank you Bill!) he would never be anywhere need justifiable to that insane price tag.
And why anyone is getting their hopes up about summer signings I do not know.
Geoff Edwards
34   Posted 06/06/2011 at 13:27:54

Report abuse

Brian, there's a theory here in Ger that Klose has suffered from Bayern's style of play in the last couple of seasons under Van Gaal, i.e. very slow tempo, short passing etc. Whilst he's thrived at int'l level as Ger put in more crosses and like to get the ball forward and up to him more quickly. Personally I wouldn't mind him getting a chance for us depending on wages etc.
Tom Astley
35   Posted 06/06/2011 at 14:20:04

Report abuse

Wickham is a Liverpool fan anyway. His 'hero' is Fernando Torres. He won't be interested in joining us (
Gavin Ramejkis
36   Posted 06/06/2011 at 15:02:55

Report abuse

Geoff #34 any more info on why Bayern shipped Podolski out as he and Klose are lethal for the national side as a partnership, Klose and Luca Toni seems a really odd partnership. I know Podolski got a bad injury but has come back but didn't get a look in before being shipped out.
James Stewart
37   Posted 06/06/2011 at 16:17:02

Report abuse

Podolski is a real class act would love to see that left foot at Goodison!

Klose will be looking for a big payday and I would be very very surprised to see him at Everton! Can't doubt his quality though. One of the best finishers around.

Demba Ba is the one I would really love to see sign for us though. I was gutted when we didn't beat West Ham to him. The guy is class. Pace, power and can finish and work ethic is very much up there which Moyes will love.
If you had a fit Saha and Ba up front together that would be some partnership!
Geoff Edwards
38   Posted 06/06/2011 at 20:30:29

Report abuse

Gavin, not 100% sure but as far as I know Podolski just didn't settle in Munich. He's a Cologne boy through and through and was a bit homesick and he's the type who needs an arm round him, which players don't tend to get at Bayern. He gets that with Loew in the national set-up, which is very settled and seems quite tight-knit, which prob helps Klose too. They both have phenomenal records for Germany you're right. Podolski: 25 yrs old, 87 caps, 40-odd goals, unbelievable.
Marcus Choo
39   Posted 06/06/2011 at 23:05:01

Report abuse

Another one for Toffeewebbers to discuss.

Pros: He's free. Not too old (25 years). Plays in midfield either on the right or the left, something we're not exactly bursting with talent in terms of squad numbers. Current international for Sweden.

I wouldn't mind us trying to sign him up. Sure he's not Messi, but I think he could benefit Everton in terms of numbers, especially if Moyes chooses to cash in on Bilyaletdinov or Rodwell/Fellaini. Competition for his services comes from Blackburn, Stoke, Newcastle, and Sunderland. For those of us who think we could do better, I think we have to adjust our sights slightly lower. We're not in the position to bid for Sneijder or even Parker in my opinion...

Kieran fitzgerald
40   Posted 06/06/2011 at 23:06:43

Report abuse

I know Robbie Keane's name has popped up a lot every time there is a transfer window. And I know that people on Toffeeweb are divided about what he would bring to the team. I have to say though that Robbie Keane's performance on Saturday in a very defensive and workmanlike Irish team was immense.

He was constantly running, was trying to create play and drive the team forward and has no hesitation in talking to his team mates, both positively and negatively when required.

I know people will say he's the wrong side of thirty and hasn't had a settled run in a team in ages, but I think that his work ethic, his willingness to lead the team and drive it forward, is something that this Everton squad would benefit hugely from. Imagine what both he and Phil Neville on the pitch would provide.

I also think with a regular game, there are still a lot of goals in Keane. His link up play and his ability to play up front or from deep would be ideal in an Everton team that is sometimes bereft of creativity. Also, considering we may be blooding a number of younger players next season, his experience and leadership abilities both on the pitch and in the dressing room would be brilliant.

I know that Spurs may not want to sell a player to us, and his wage demands may be a stumbling block. I do think though that he is definitely worth a punt.

Fran Mitchell
41   Posted 07/06/2011 at 01:43:40

Report abuse

You're saying we should spend 15million on a player who scored less goals (8) in an entire season than both Yakubu (11) and Vaughan (9) scored in 5 months?

No doubt a quality yongster with potential, yet his hype seems to be a little over-the-top. If it wasn't for the red-tops I wouldn't now the lad existed.

Seen as we don't have any cash, then we should go for Larsson. Would fit ito our style, can play on the right side and offer competition for Mikel in the middle. No brainer for me.

I would take Klose. If the wages are good, he has the potential to have one or 2 good season. 15 goals from him and we could challenge for Europe. Him with Beckford would suit our play, complement each other and would score goals. Saha could make his monthly appearance and give Klose a rest.

Other than that we should be looking for good players who've lost their way a little, and could be available on loan with view to a transfer.
Ian McDowell
42   Posted 07/06/2011 at 12:32:13

Report abuse

I see Alan Smith has just been released by Newcastle.
Ciarán McGlone
43   Posted 07/06/2011 at 12:35:20

Report abuse

Another article suggesting we should buy the best young talent around - when will the people writing these articles wake up?

We are neither capable of covering the costs of fantastic players like Chamberlain, or being an attractive proposition.

Ramsay is the obvious example, by all accounts we offered more - but he went to Arsenal - and look were he is now - on the edge of being a superstar - if he'd have come here he'd still be sitting on the bench - or worse - playing as a winger.
James Marshall
44   Posted 07/06/2011 at 14:27:52

Report abuse

I haven't read this thread, but I have a question - this guy Wickham; where are we getting the money from to buy him exactly? Did I miss a meeting and we all of a sudden have loads of cash to spend? I was still under the impression we didnt have a pot to piss in.

Miroslav Klose? Hahahaha - why!?

Bothroyd for nowt is yer best bet.

Charlie Adam? No thanks - I really dislike that red shite loving nobhead despite him being quite a good player.

Who's the other one we're buying.....?....errr...oh yeah, Lionel Messi for £2.50 a a family pack of monster munch - watch this space.
Sam Hoare
45   Posted 08/06/2011 at 10:17:58

Report abuse

Bored at work so thought i might rally up some more frivolous transfer chat. Even though i know MK does not approve of such thing, it just about sustains me through the day. So....

Boothroyd: This one has been going around for a week or so now. In my opinion, not good enough but if his wage demands are low then its no transfer fee for a 1 capped English International who does seem to know where the net is and at 6'3 offers a target man alternative to Vic. So why not.

Klose: A world class striker in his time. But i believe that time is over. Still scoring at International level but a real dearth of goals for Bayern indicate he may not be worth the huge wages we would have to pay him. Probably going to Lazio.

Demba Ba; Would be my choice of the 3 strikers we are most linked to. Younger and with an impressive goal return in the last 3 or so seasons. Reports suggest that he might be a bit of a mercenary, if true he'll probably be playing for Sunderland or Newcastle next season.

Charlie Adam: A fresh link today that Adam might be up for grabs with Man U favouring Modric and Liverpool about to complete on the overpriced Henderson. Would be quite a coup and though seemingly unlikely, we might be aided by his agent being none other than Moyes' brother.

Danny Welbeck- On loan. Why not? Though would prefer Sturridge.

Other players I wouldn't mind us having a look at Seb Larsson (free), David Vaughan (free), Victor Obinna (?), Messi (?).

In terms of outgoing, yak and Yobo should be soon off to Turkey for not much deniro and Rodwell is out of favour apparently at Man U so unless City make a bid then Moyes will no longer have even a modest transfer chest unless he opts to sell player of the season, Bainesy to City or the Arse. Second season in a row that we sell our previous player of the season? Hopefully not.

Please let me know your trivial gossip and random titbits. I do have a feeling there will be a lot of cash splashed this Summer. Shame none of it will be ours.

Tony Cheek
46   Posted 08/06/2011 at 10:19:22

Report abuse


Everton's interest is said to have been genuine but the Merseysiders were unwilling to meet the 32-year-old's £80,000-a-week wage demands. WHAT?? 80 BLEEDING THOUSAND A WEEK!!!! The man is 32 for christ sake!!! Let this one go Moyesy!!!

James Marshall
47   Posted 08/06/2011 at 14:24:49

Report abuse

Klose has only ever scored goals for teams that create, i.e. he doesn't do anything other than get on the end of things - we're not exactly Hungary '54 when it comes to creativity!
Roy Rennison
48   Posted 08/06/2011 at 15:34:59

Report abuse

Heard a few weeks ago Rodwell was going to City or United depending on the highest bidder.Just spotted this link and hoping its Rodwell and not Bainesy.
Dave Lynch
49   Posted 08/06/2011 at 18:38:37

Report abuse

Bothroyd! God give me fucking strength, is that what it has come to?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment to the MailBag, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and MailBag submissions across the site.

© ToffeeWeb

We use cookies to enhance your experience on ToffeeWeb and to enable certain features. By using the website you are consenting to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.